Dating Challenges: What Should You Talk About on a First Date?

Although I know plenty of people who have met their romantic partners on dating apps, there are also many people who find dating apps to be discouraging.

Dating: What Should You Talk About?

In recent years many of my single clients have complained that dating has become difficult  within the last several years (see my article: Why Was Dating So Much Easier in the Past?).

Why Has Dating Become So Difficult?

Many clients complain that the whole process is disheartening and fraught with problems (see my article: Why Do Some People Prefer Dating Apps to Meeting in Person?).

Assuming that two people make it through the initial stages and meet up for a first date, clients complain that the in person experience can be disappointing and awkward.  

Many of them say they're not even sure what to talk because the dating process has become more like a job search with people coming to the first date with many "interview questions" which is their approach to not wanting to waste time if their date isn't a potential match.

In general, these problems include:

• Technology: Dating apps have made dating impersonal for many people. Swiping through hundreds (if not thousands) of profiles can feel like you're in a highly competitive process, especially on dating sites where pictures are the main focus. No doubt dating apps also allow you to potentially meet many more people than you would in person (at least in theory), but many people believe the problems with dating apps outweighs the advantages.

• Know What You Want: Just like anything else, when you only have a vague idea of what you want, the dating experience can be disappointing. So, take some time to figure out what you're looking for (beyond looks) before you begin the process. You can also be reasonably flexible and take into account that you might click with someone who doesn't meet your full criteria because there are certain unexpected qualities you might like about them.

• Ghosting: The impersonal nature of dating also makes it easier to disconnect and disappear without an explanation. Many clients have said this is a regular part of their experience and ghosting has taken a toll on their mental health.

Dating and Ghosting

• Increased Risk: Since you don't always know who you're dealing with, there is an increased risk of being scammed or worse. If you set up a time to meet, always choose a public place. Even if you feel very lonely, don't fall for dating app scams where someone says they have fallen madly in love with you and declares you're in a relationship before you even meet as a way to set up instant intimacy. Then, inevitably, you get the message that they desperately need money for their father's medical bills and they ask you, as their partner, to send them money. You might think you wouldn't ever fall for one of these scams, but when you're lonely and you've had many prior discouraging dating experiences, it's easy to fall for a scam.

• Hook Up Culture: The combination of the technology, which is impersonal, and hook up culture, can create situations where people don't develop the necessary interpersonal and communication skills to be able to meet and date successfully. As a result, there might be a mismatch in terms of what each person wants. If you want to be in a committed relationship but the other person really only wants to hook up, you might be disappointed (see my article: Can Hookups Be Safer and More Satisfying For Heterosexual Women?)

• Loss of Control: Many people who use dating apps feel like they're being compared unfavorably to hundreds of other people on the site. This is often a fair assessment because some daters keep searching on the dating apps because they believe they can always find "someone better" if they keep looking. 

• Difficulty Figuring Out What Other People Want: Just because someone says they want to be in a relationship doesn't necessarily mean that's what they really want. And, even if they want to be in a relationship, they might not want to be in the type of relationship you want. For instance, if you want to be in a monogamous relationship, you might meet many people who want to be in a consensual nonmonogamous relationship and vice versa. Being honest is so important to avoid disappointment and hurt feelings (see my article: What Are Your Dating Expectations?).

• Dating App Burnout: Many clients describe the process of using dating apps as  exhausting. Looking at so many dating profiles and having online conversations with multiple people can be overwhelming. People who use dating apps who don't experience burnout often say that they limit their time on the apps. They designate a certain amount of time and then they get off. They might even take off a few weeks when it becomes too much. 

What Should You Talk About on a First Date?

Assuming you're able to navigate all the challenges involved with dating apps, another challenge is what to talk about on the first date.

Obviously, there's no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, but I think it's important to try to maintain an open and positive attitude while being discerning in the process.

Here are some tips you might find helpful for conversations on a first date:

• Be Curious: Instead of just talking about yourself, which is a common complaint among people who date, get curious about the person you're with. This doesn't mean asking them 100 questions. Instead focus casually on what you want to know about them.

What Do You Talk About on a First Date?

• Be Reasonably Open : While you're not going to share your whole life story or talk about all your exes or bad dating experiences, be appropriately open to talking about yourself in a way that let's your date know who you are. Keep it light. You can talk about your interests, hobbies, travel experiences, for instance, but try not to be so open that you're divulging things about yourself that will make your date cringe or make you feel embarrassed afterwards.

• Don't Dominate the Conversation: You want to be open and curious but, as previously mentioned, you don't want to engage in a monologue which will make your date look for the nearest exit. You're not responsible for carrying the whole conversation, so let your date take part in the conversation too.

• Feeling Awkward? You Might Say So: It's reasonable to feel a little awkward on a first date. Instead of pretending to feel more confident than you actually feel, admit to feeling a little awkward. This will probably take some pressure off you. It might also help your date to relax a little too because, chances are, they're feeling awkward too. By admitting this, you might even laugh about it and ease some of the tension.

Feeling Awkward During a First Date is Common

• Avoid Certain Topics: If you continue to date this person, there will be time to talk about certain topics that are important to you, but don't do it on the first date or too early on in the dating experience. Generally, topics to avoid include:
• Religion 
• Politics 
• Past Relationships
• Your Finances (or theirs)
• Your Traumatic Experiences (or theirs)

• Stick to Topics That Help You Get to Know Each Other in a Comfortable Way: For a first date, there are many topics that will help you to get to know each other without veering into cringeworthy subjects. These topics include:
• Travel
  
• Hobbies
• Special Interests
• Books
  
• Movies, and so on

• Don't Set Up False Expectations About Future Dates: You might realize that you and your date aren't a good match, but you might also feel awkward about how to handle this situation. There's an episode on "Friends" where Chandler dates Rachel's boss, Joanna. After the first date, he knows he doesn't want to see her again, but he doesn't know what to say so he tells her that he'll call her when he knows he has no intention of calling her. He just doesn't know how to handle that awkward silence at the end of their lunch date. Although it might be awkward, try to:

• Be polite and tactful

• Acknowledge what you enjoyed the date and getting to know them.

• At the same time, tell your date you don't feel a connection so you don't feel it will go any further. It can be awkward, but if you're polite and tactful, your date might appreciate that you're not going to waste their time.

Conclusion

Dating can be challenging, especially if you only use dating apps, as most people do these days.

A First Date: Keep It Light

Depending upon your circumstances, you might find it easier to use a combination of different ways to meet people including: meeting people through groups dedicated to your interests or hobbies, volunteering, asking friends about eligible single friends and going to other in-person events.

About Me

I am a licensed New York City psychotherapist, hypnotherapist, EMDR, AEDP, EFT (for couples), Somatic Experiencing and Sex Therapist.

I work with individual adults and couples on a variety of issues.

To find out more about me, visit my website: Josephine Ferraro, LCSW - NYC Psychotherapist.

To set up a consultation, call me at (917) 742-2624 during business hours or email me.